Wellsley Farms Butter

Discovering the Creamy, Delicious Options from Wellsley Farms

Butter is one of life’s simple pleasures. Slathered on a piece of crusty bread or melted over steamed vegetables, great butter can transform an ordinary meal into a delicious experience. This is why it’s so important to choose a quality brand you can trust. That’s where Wellsley Farms shines.

Wellsley Farms offers a wide selection of premium butters made from fresh cream sourced from farms across the United States. From salted to unsalted, whipped to European-style, Wellsley Farms provides top-notch butter options for every taste and cooking need. As an added bonus, their butters come at a great value while upholding rigorous quality standards.

If you’re in the market for a new go-to butter, Wellsley Farms is a brand worth exploring. This buying guide will walk you through everything you need to know, from types of butters to nutritional information and more. Let’s dive in and discover why so many bakers, chefs and home cooks choose Wellsley Farms as their butter of choice!

An Overview of Wellsley Farms Butter

Wellsley Farms offers a range of salted and unsalted butter options, including their famous whipped butter spread. Their traditional stick butters contain 100% all-natural cream and real sea salt, with no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Wellsley Farms states that the cream used in their butters comes from cows not treated with artificial growth hormones (RBST-free).

Several of their butters are specifically formulated for baking, providing the ideal fat content and texture for cookies, cakes and pastries. Other options mimic premium European-style butters with a higher fat content. Wellsley Farms butters are produced in the United States and carry the Real California seal certifying the quality of their ingredients.

Wellsley Farms butters are available for purchase at BJ’s Wholesale Clubs nationwide. They come in convenient printable tubs, sticks and 9 oz. whirl packs. Prices are very reasonable, ranging from $3.49 for a box of four sticks to $7.49 for a 3 lb. tub. Read on for a closer look at the offerings from Wellsley Farms!

Salted vs. Unsalted Wellsley Farms Butter

When it comes to baking and cooking, salted or unsalted butter is more than a matter of personal taste. The salt content actually impacts the texture and how the butter performs. Here’s an overview of Wellsley Farms options:

Salted Butter

• Contains approximately 1/4 tsp salt per 1 tbsp butter
• Provides a bolder, saltier flavor
• Best for cooking, sautéing and baking sturdy items like dinner rolls where you want to highlight the butter taste
• Varieties include Wellsley Farms Salted Butter, Unsalted Butter and Sea Salted Butter sticks

Unsalted Butter

• Contains no added salt (salt-free)
• Has a purer, sweeter dairy flavor showcasing the cream
• Allows full control over salt added during cooking and baking
• Best for more delicate baking like cakes, cookies and pastry crusts
• Varieties include Wellsley Farms Unsalted Butter sticks and Whipped Unsalted Butter tubs

So in summary, salted butter like Wellsley Farms Salted brings its own saltiness, while unsalted allows you to add just the right amount of salt yourself.

Where to Buy Wellsley Farms Butter

The number one place to buy Wellsley Farms butter is BJ’s Wholesale Club locations. As the exclusive retailer of Wellsley Farms, you can find their full selection of butters at BJ’s stores across the country.

Wellsley Farms butters like their salted sticks, whipped tubs and European-style options are all available in-club at BJ’s. You’ll find them stocked in the dairy aisle alongside other BJ’s brand dairy items like milk, yogurt and eggs.

BJ’s members can also shop online and have Wellsley Farms butters delivered through BJ’s website or mobile app. Opt for in-store pickup or home delivery to get your favorites quickly and easily.

The only other place you may be able to find select Wellsley Farms butters is on third party websites like eBay or Amazon. However, your best bet is sticking with BJ’s Wholesale Club for the widest selection and competitive member pricing. Check the BJ’s website to find a club near you today!

Wellsley Farms Butter Prices

One of the biggest appeals of Wellsley Farms butter is the exceptional value for the price. Especially compared to premium and imported brands, Wellsley Farms provides gourmet quality at a fraction of the cost.

Some examples of Wellsley Farms butter prices at BJ’s include:

• Salted Butter Sticks (4 pack) – $3.49
• European Style Butter (4 pack) – $3.99
• Sea Salted Butter (4 pack) – $3.99
• Unsalted Butter Sticks (4 pack) – $3.49
• Whipped Unsalted Butter (3 lb tub) – $7.49
• Lighter Salted Butter (4 pack) – $3.59
• Honey Butter (7.5 oz) – $3.49
• Maple Butter (7.5 oz) – $3.49
• Cinnamon Raisin Butter (7.5 oz) – $3.49

So you’re looking at only $0.87 to $0.99 per stick, which is very affordable compared to premium butter brands. Even their 3 lb. tub of whipped butter is just $2.49 per pound – an incredible value.

Taking advantage of BJ’s member pricing makes Wellsley Farms butter a budget-friendly option with gourmet quality. Plus, you can save even more by buying larger quantities at wholesale clubs.

Wellsley Farms Butter at BJ’s Wholesale Club

As a brand exclusive to BJ’s Wholesale Club, the best selection of Wellsley Farms butter is always found at BJ’s locations. Club members have access to all of Wellsley Farms’ salted, unsalted, whipped, baking and flavored butter options.

Some of the customer favorites include:

• Salted Butter Sticks – Classic creamy salted butter for cooking, baking and spreading
• Whipped Butter Tubs – Smooth, spreadable whipped butter that’s perfect for biscuits, cornbread and pancakes
• European Style Butter – Offers a higher fat content and rich taste inspired by luxury French and Irish butters
• Honey Butter – Whipped butter blended with pure honey for a naturally sweet twist
• Maple Butter – Real maple syrup gives this spreadable butter a touch of maple sweetness
• Cinnamon Raisin Butter – Cinnamon and raisins swirled into creamy whipped butter

BJ’s also offers exclusive Season’s Choice holiday flavors like Pumpkin Spice and Gingerbread butter, available for a limited time.

With so many options to choose from, BJ’s is the ultimate one-stop-shop for all your Wellsley Farms butter needs!

Wellsley Farms Butter Ingredients

When it comes to ingredients, Wellsley Farms believes in keeping things simple. Their butters contain just a few high-quality ingredients:

• Cream – Wellsley Farms butters are made from only 100% pure pasteurized cream. They state their cream comes from cows not treated with the artificial growth hormone rBST.
• Salt – Some varieties like Salted Butter contain real sea salt added for flavor. The salt crystals add delicate briny notes.
• Flavorings – In options like Cinnamon Raisin Butter, extra ingredients like cinnamon and raisins are added to turn basic butter into a sweet treat.
• Preservatives – Wellsley Farms butters contain no artificial preservatives, colors or flavors. Only natural ingredients are used to maintain freshness.

The simple, straightforward ingredients result in butters with a pure, delicious real cream taste. You can pronounce everything on the label and feel good about what you’re eating.

Are Wellsley Farms Cows Grass-Fed?

While Wellsley Farms does not specifically claim their butter is made from the milk of grass-fed cows, there are a few positive indicators that point in that direction:

• Pasture-raised – Wellsley Farms states their cows are pasture-raised, which often correlates with at least some access to grass and grazing.
• RBST-free – Their website mentions the cows are not treated with the artificial hormone rBST, which is commonly avoided in grass-fed dairy production.
• High CLA content – Testing shows Wellsley Farms butters contain higher levels of CLA fatty acids, which are associated with a grass-fed diet.

So while not 100% confirmed grass-fed, there are several promising signs the cows producing cream for Wellsley Farms enjoy access to pasture and grass. This may contribute to the exceptionally fresh, creamy taste their butters deliver.

Nutritional Profile of Wellsley Farms Butter

Here is the basic nutritional profile for Wellsley Farms Salted Butter, based on a 1 tbsp (14g) serving:

• Calories – 100
• Fat – 11g (17% DV)
  • Saturated Fat – 7g (35% DV)
• Cholesterol – 30mg (10% DV)
• Sodium – 90mg (4% DV)
• Protein – 0g
• Carbohydrates – 0g

As expected, the majority of calories in Wellsley Farms butter comes from fat, especially saturated fat. The saturated fat and cholesterol levels are also quite high.

However, the fatty acid content is typical of dairy butter. Some research suggests dairy fat may not negatively impact blood cholesterol levels as previously assumed.

Overall, Wellsley Farms butter can be enjoyed as part of a balanced diet. Those limiting saturated fat or watching cholesterol may prefer lighter butter options.

Baking with Wellsley Farms Butter

For baking, it’s helpful to choose a butter with the right fat content and texture. Wellsley Farms offers several butters specially formulated for optimal baking performance:

Salted Butter

• All-purpose option suitable for most basic baking
• Provides rich flavor in cookies, cakes, muffins, etc.

European Style Butter

• Higher fat content – similar to premium French & Irish butter
• Excellent for laminating puff pastry dough and croissants
• Also superb for rich butter cookies and cakes

Unsalted Butter

• No added salt allows full control over saltiness
• Perfect for more delicate baked goods like shortbread

Lighter Butter

• 34% less saturated fat than regular butter
• Has similar taste and performance for a healthier option

No matter which you choose, Wellsley Farms butters provide the gold standard in taste and quality to make your baked goods shine. The natural, real ingredients let the flavor of the butter take center stage.

How Wellsley Farms Butter Compares to Kerrygold

Kerrygold is a popular imported butter from Ireland praised for its rich flavor and lush texture. But how does it compare to Wellsley Farms? Here are the key differences:

• Grass-fed – Kerrygold cows are grass-fed year-round whereas Wellsley Farms butter may not be 100% grass-fed.
• Fat content – Kerrygold is 80% butterfat. Wellsley Farms is standard American butterfat around 80-82%.
• Price – Kerrygold is more expensive, usually $4 to $5 per pack compared to $3.50 for Wellsley Farms.
• Salt – Kerrygold is lightly salted. Wellsley Farms offers salted & unsalted.
• Flavor – Fans say Kerrygold has a richer, nuttier, more complex taste. But Wellsley Farms still offers a fresher, creamier flavor than regular butter.

While Kerrygold wins for grass-fed purity and decadent flavor, Wellsley Farms provides nearly equal quality at a much lower cost. It’s ideal for everyday cooking and baking use.

Fat Percentage in Wellsley Farms Butter

The milkfat content or percentage of fat gives butter its rich, indulgent taste and texture. Here is how Wellsley Farms butters stack up:

• Salted Butter – Contains 82% milkfat. This is the standard level found in most grocery store stick butters. Offers great taste for everyday use.
• Whipped Butter – Has a similar 80-82% milkfat content to stick butter, but with a lighter, fluffier texture from whipping.
• European Style – These sticks are 83% milkfat, similar to premium European-style butters. The extra fat means more richness.
• Lighter Butter – With around 51% milkfat, this variety contains 34% less fat than regular Wellsley Farms butter for a healthier option.

No matter which you choose, Wellsley Farms butters offer a high-quality milkfat content resulting in smooth, creamy, spreadable perfection.

Is Wellsley Farms Butter Gluten Free?

The good news is that all Wellsley Farms butter varieties are gluten-free!

Being made from just pure cream and salt, Wellsley Farms butters contain no gluten sources like wheat, rye, barley or malt. This makes them a safe option for those with celiac disease or gluten sensitivities.

Wellsley Farms butters are produced in a facility that also processes wheat, milk, egg and soy. But with their simple ingredients that are naturally gluten-free, cross-contamination is minimal.

As long as you stick to their regular butter offerings and avoid any flavored varieties with added ingredients, you can enjoy Wellsley Farms butter worry-free even on a gluten-free diet. Their butter spreads smoothly and tastes delicious!

Is Wellsley Farms Butter Organic?

At this time, Wellsley Farms butters are not certified organic. Their butter is produced conventionally using quality ingredients and responsible practices.

Here are some key points about the sourcing of Wellsley Farms butter:

• Cows are not treated with the artificial growth hormone rBST
• Pasture-raised cows with likely some access to grass
• No antibiotics or toxic pesticides
• Milk and cream from USA farms

So while not certified organic, Wellsley Farms does emphasize more natural methods to produce a wholesome, quality butter. Their butter may appeal to those who want to avoid hormones and prefer pasture-raised cows.

For certified organic, look for options from brands like Horizon Organic, Organic Valley, or Kerrygold. But Wellsley Farms makes a fine conventional butter if organic is not a necessity.

Freezing Wellsley Farms Butter

Need more butter than you can use before it expires? Extend the shelf life by freezing excess Wellsley Farms butter for long-term storage.

Here are some tips for freezing butter:

• Wrap tightly in plastic wrap, waxed paper or foil to prevent freezer burn. Remove as much air as possible.
• Portion butter into usable amounts so you can thaw just what you need.
• Use freezer-safe containers or bags for easy storage. Freezer bags work great.
• Freeze up to 12 months for best quality and taste.
• Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before using. Do not microwave – this can cause melting and separation.

With proper freezing techniques, Wellsley Farms butter retains its fresh flavor, smooth texture and baking performance for months to come. Stock up during sales to save!

How Wellsley Farms Butter is Packaged

Wellsley Farms butters come packaged in a few convenient shapes and sizes:

Stick butter – The classic 1/4 pound stick wrapped in parchment paper. Sold in 4-stick boxes.

Tubs – Easy-to-spread whipped butter in plastic tubs. Available in 3 lb. sizes.

Foil sleeves – Some holiday flavors come packaged in colorful foil sleeves.

Whirl packs – Individual 1/4 lb. sticks swaddled in plastic for grab-and-go convenience.

Wellsley Farms stick butters feature traditional 1/4 pound sizing with handy portion lines for cutting, measuring, and recipes. The sticks are wrapped in parchment paper bearing the signature Wellsley Farms branding.

For mess-free spreading, their whipped tubs are ideal. The resealable plastic packaging keeps the whipped butter fresh.

No matter which you choose, Wellsley Farms uses quality packaging to deliver butter that’s smooth, delicious and easy to serve.

Flavored Wellsley Farms Butter Options

Beyond classic salted and unsalted varieties, Wellsley Farms crafts a tantalizing selection of flavored butters:

• Honey Butter – Sweetened with smooth, creamy honey
• Maple Butter – Real maple syrup adds authentic maple flavor
• Cinnamon Raisin Butter – Cinnamon spice and plump raisins swirled throughout
• Pumpkin Spice Butter – Seasonal and limited-edition for fall baking
• Gingerbread Butter – Perfect for the holidays with gingerbread flavor

These options transform ordinary butter into a mouthwatering treat. Slather them over muffins, pancakes and biscuits or add them to recipes for extra flavor. The options from Wellsley Farms are endless for flavored butters!

Wellsley Farms Butter: Keto & Paleo Diet

With its high fat content and zero carbs, Wellsley Farms butter fits perfectly into diets like the keto, paleo or low-carb lifestyles.

Some key points:

• Contains no carbohydrates, sugar or additives – only fat and flavor
• Provides healthy fats for fuel and energy
• Adds rich flavor to keto recipes without carbs
• Helps satisfy cravings for bread, biscuits and rolls
• Salted butter contributes important electrolytes like sodium and potassium

Slather Wellsley butter on keto bread, add it to your morning coffee, or bake up some keto cookies or cakes. Wellsley Farms butter is a versatile staple in low-carb kitchens.

Wellsley Farms Butter Reviews

Wellsley Farms butters consistently earn rave reviews for their fresh taste, smooth texture and performance. Here are some thoughts from real butter lovers:

“This is the best butter I have ever used for baking. Cookies, pie crust, everything turns out perfect.”

“Tastes like real creamy butter, not the fake stuff. Great price at BJ’s.”

“Very rich tasting and nice consistency. We use it for everything from toast to cooking to baking.”

“You can really tell this is quality butter. It makes my homemade bread and dinner rolls excellent.”

5/5 stars is a common rating for Wellsley Farms butters. Customers agree they offer an unbeatable combination of quality and value. The butters spread smoothly, taste great on bread or veggies, and make baked goods shine.

Shelf Life of Wellsley Farms Butter

When properly stored, Wellsley Farms butter lasts a surprisingly long time. Here’s how long the butter stays fresh:

Unopened – Around 4 to 6 months past the “best by” date printed on the packaging.

Refrigerator – Lasts about 3 weeks after opening when refrigerated below 40°F.

Freezer – Keeps the original quality for up to 1 year in the freezer below 0°F.

The best storage tips:

• Refrigerate after opening and use within 3 weeks
• Seal the wrapper tightly or store in an airtight container
• Keep away from heat sources and bright light

With proper storage, Wellsley Farms butters retain their deliciously smooth texture and fresh flavor for months to come. Stock up at BJ’s without worrying about waste!

Everything You Need to Know About Wellsley Farms Butter

From its impeccable quality to incredibly fair pricing, it’s easy to see why Wellsley Farms has become the butter of choice for so many. Their wide selection meets every need in the kitchen from baking to cooking to spreading.

Made with simple, natural ingredients, Wellsley Farms offers premium butter taste and performance at a fraction of the cost. Their cows enjoy a wholesome pasture-raised diet to produce exceptionally fresh and creamy milk and cream.

So for your next recipe, buyer’s club trip or just everyday use, choose the butter brand that delivers on all fronts: Wellsley Farms. Your bread, vegetables and baked goods will thank you with buttery, delicious flavor in every bite. Satisfaction is truly guaranteed with Wellsley Farms.