Wellsley Farms Ice Cream

Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth with Wellsley Farms Ice Cream

As a lifelong ice cream lover, I can confidently say that Wellsley Farms ice cream is one of the tastiest store-bought brands out there. Their traditional flavors like chocolate and vanilla are creamy and indulgent, with a rich texture that puts them above generic grocery store ice cream. But Wellsley Farms really shines with their fun, innovative flavors that make you feel like a kid again. Who can resist flavors like Cookie Dough Extreme, Snickerdoodle, and Coffee Toffee Crunch? Not me!

I love having a stash of Wellsley Farms ice cream in my freezer for those nights when I’m in need of some comfort food and a little sweet treat. Their pints are the perfect single-serve size when the ice cream craving hits. But with so many great flavors to choose from, it can be tough to decide which ones to buy. That’s why I put together this ultimate Wellsley Farms ice cream buying guide to take the guesswork out of your next ice cream run.

An Overview of the Wellsley Farms Ice Cream Lineup

Wellsley Farms ice cream comes in a wide range of flavors so there’s something for everyone. Their traditional flavors include chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, cookies and cream, and mint chocolate chip. Simple but delicious. They also offer more unique flavors like Cake Batter, Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup, Mocha Almond Fudge, and Brownie Batter.

For another level of decadence, check out their Extreme flavors like Cookie Dough Extreme and Chocolate Extreme, loaded with chunks of chocolate cookies or fudge. Snickerdoodle, Coffee Toffee Crunch, and Butter Pecan are also excellent choices if you like mix-ins in your ice cream. And don’t forget seasonal options like Pumpkin Pie or Peppermint Stick around the holidays.

If you avoid dairy, Wellsley Farms non-dairy options like chocolate or vanilla coconut milk ice cream are amazing alternatives. Those watching their sugar intake will appreciate their line of lower sugar ice creams in flavors like chocolate and vanilla. Basically, there’s a Wellsley Farms ice cream to satisfy any craving!

Where to Buy Wellsley Farms Ice Cream

The great thing about Wellsley Farms ice cream is that it’s available at major grocery chains nationwide. I usually pick it up at my local Kroger since they have a huge selection to choose from in their frozen aisle. But you can also find Wellsley Farms ice cream at chains like Safeway, Ralph’s, King Soopers, Fry’s, Fred Meyer, Harris Teeter, Roundy’s, and Smith’s.

Wellsley Farms ice cream is one of Kroger’s private label brands. So if you have a Kroger-owned store in your area, you’re almost guaranteed to find these pints stocked in the ice cream freezer case. Just look for the black and white Wellsley Farms packaging.

If you’re looking for a wider flavor selection, be sure to browse the ice cream offerings at Whole Foods. They carry unique Wellsley Farms flavors beyond what you’ll typically find at mainstream grocers.

And for the ultimate convenience, many grocery delivery services like Instacart allow you to order Wellsley Farms ice cream online. Get your fix delivered right to your door!

Nutrition Information and Ingredients

When I indulge in ice cream, I don’t want to feel guilty about it. That’s why I appreciate that Wellsley Farms ice cream doesn’t overload their recipes with artificial colors, flavors, or sweeteners. Their ingredient lists are relatively simple and made with recognizable ingredients.

Nearly all Wellsley Farms ice cream varieties are made with a base of cream, milk, sugar, and natural flavors. Most flavors also contain egg yolks and thickeners like guar gum or locust bean gum. For mix-ins, you’ll find real inclusions like cookies, chocolate chips, peanut butter cups, or toffee bits.

As far as nutrition, a 1/2 cup serving of Wellsley Farms ice cream ranges from 140 to 180 calories depending on the flavor. Each serving also provides 4-6g of protein and 14-18g of fat, mostly from the dairy ingredients. The sugar content is moderate at around 20-24g per serving.

Compared to premium ice cream brands, Wellsley Farms has similar nutrition stats. Though a small serving still packs a decent amount of calories and saturated fat, the ingredients are about as wholesome as it gets for ice cream. Moderation is key!

Flavor Reviews and Recommendations

I’ve taste tested just about every Wellsley Farms ice cream variety over the years. Here are some of my thoughts and recommendations on their extensive flavor lineup:

Chocolate

This simple chocolate ice cream is ultra creamy and packed with rich cocoa flavor. It’s great topped with chocolate syrup or crushed Oreos if you want to take it up a notch.

Vanilla

You can’t go wrong with Wellsley Farms vanilla ice cream. It nails the perfect vanilla sweetness without tasting artificial. I like to dress it up with fruit or blended into milkshakes.

Strawberry

The strawberry flavor tastes like real fruit, not artificial candy strawberry flavor. The tiny flecks of strawberry puree throughout give it an extra berry kick.

Cookies and Cream

This classic flavor features loads of crumbled Oreo-like cookies swirled throughout rich vanilla ice cream. The cookie-to-ice cream ratio is spot on.

Coffee Toffee Crunch

For the coffee lovers, this flavor combines smooth coffee ice cream with bits of toffee that add nice texture and a buttery sweetness. The caffeinekick is a nice bonus too!

Mint Chocolate Chip

Wellsley Farms mint chocolate chip strikes the perfect minty-sweet balance. And it has just the right amount of mini chocolate chips nestled inside.

Cookie Dough Extreme

True to its name, this ice cream is stuffed full of so much edible chocolate chip cookie dough that you get a chunk in nearly every bite. Decadent and delicious!

Snickerdoodle

This unique flavor features crunchy cinnamon cookie crumbles swirled into creamy cinnamon ice cream. Like eating a frozen snickerdoodle cookie – so good!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate and peanut butter are a match made in heaven. This ice cream delivers big peanut butter cups and swirls of peanut butter rippled throughout rich chocolate ice cream.

Butter Pecan

The butter pecan ice cream has intense nutty pecan flavor and ample pecan pieces mixed throughout. Perfect for pecan pie lovers!

Is it Organic or Gluten-Free?

Two common questions I get asked about Wellsley Farms ice cream are: is it organic and is it gluten-free?

Unfortunately, Wellsley Farms ice cream is not organic. The dairy ingredients are from conventional non-organic sources. I know organic options are preferred by many, but you can take comfort that Wellsley Farms does not contain artificial growth hormones in their dairy.

As far as gluten, some Wellsley Farms ice cream flavors are already gluten-free certified right on the packaging, like their chocolate and vanilla varieties. However, flavors that contain cookie or cake pieces are likely not gluten-free due to the wheat-based ingredients. If gluten is a concern for you, I recommend sticking to their chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, or coconut milk ice cream varieties to be on the safe side.

Comparing Wellsley Farms and Ben & Jerry’s

If you’re a fan of Ben & Jerry’s ice cream (and really, who isn’t?), you may be wondering how Wellsley Farms stacks up. Ben & Jerry’s is known for their whimsical flavor names, mix-ins, and ultra-smooth and creamy texture.

Overall, I would say Wellsley Farms ice cream is comparable in quality to Ben & Jerry’s, though the flavors are generally more traditional. They both use high quality dairy ingredients that deliver rich, indulgent ice cream.

Ben & Jerry’s does have more over-the-top flavors like Cherries Garcia or Chunky Monkey. Wellsley Farms flavors are more classic and understated. But they still have unique options like Snickerdoodle and espresso-based flavors.

One advantage of Wellsley Farms is it comes in single-serve pint sizes, whereas Ben & Jerry’s is usually sold in larger multi-serving containers. So if you live alone and want to keep temptation under control, Wellsley Farms pints are a smart choice.

And finally, when it comes to cost, Wellsley Farms has a price advantage. Their pints are often $2-3, whereas Ben & Jerry’s can run $4-6 per pint. You get great quality ice cream without the premium price tag.

No matter which brand you pick, you really can’t go wrong when ice cream is involved!

Buying Wellsley Farms Ice Cream Online

While the best place to buy Wellsley Farms ice cream is at your local grocery store freezer case, you can also find certain flavors for online delivery.

Instacart allows you to add Wellsley Farms ice cream to your grocery order for delivery from local store locations. So if you already use Instacart for groceries, it’s super easy to throw a few pints into your online order.

There are also some third party retailers that sell Wellsley Farms ice cream online for direct delivery:

• Boxed.com – Carries popular flavors like Chocolate, Vanilla, and Cookies & Cream available for delivery in bulk.
• Peapod.com – Owned by Giant Food Stores, so you can order Wellsley Farms ice cream online and have it delivered if you live in Peapod delivery areas.
• FreshDirect.com – Another grocery delivery service that includes Wellsley Farms ice cream for customers in select regions.

The selection is more limited when ordering online vs in-store. But it’s a convenient way to get Wellsley Farms flavors delivered to your doorstep. Perfect for when the ice cream craving strikes and you don’t feel like heading to the store!

Tips for Serving and Storing

Now that your freezer is fully stocked with the tastiest Wellsley Farms ice cream flavors, here are some tips to get the most enjoyment out of each pint:

• Let the ice cream sit at room temperature for 5-10 minutes before scooping for ideal softness and scoopability.
• Use an ice cream scoop and scoop against the side of the carton to get picture-perfect scoops.
• Top flavors like chocolate or vanilla with your favorite ice cream toppings – sprinkles, chocolate syrup, crushed candy bars, the possibilities are endless!
• Get creative with mixes and ice cream sandwiches using different Wellsley Farms flavors.
• Slightly thawed ice cream blends perfectly into milkshakes too.
• Seal each pint air tight and store in the back of the freezer where it’s coldest for optimal freshness.
• Unopened pints are generally good for 2-3 months past the “best by” date on the bottom.
• If ice cream gets freezer burnt or icy, letting it thaw in the fridge overnight improves the texture.

Wellsley Farms ice cream always hits the spot when I’m craving a cold, creamy treat. I hope this guide gave you some helpful tips and flavor recommendations for enjoying Wellsley Farms ice cream to the fullest. Get ready for your next late night netflix binge with a pint of your favorite flavor!